Back in 2007, I defied this silent edict and published a list of the top fifteen movies of the year rather than my usual decathlon. My rationale was entirely laudatory – there were simply more stellar films than there was available space on a catalog of 10. And while I couldn't quite label titles such as Charlie Wilson's War or Juno as one 2007's 10 best films, I couldn't in good conscience exclude them from my commemoration of the year's superlative features. I had no choice: I had to expand the list to 15.
For 2010, I'm inflating my year-end "best of" list to an even 20 films, but my reasoning this year is considerably different. My problem isn't that I saw too many great movies in 2010; my problem is that I saw too few. Don't get me wrong, the past year offered plenty of pretty good movies, but they were just that – pretty good. Maybe it's a slate of increasingly indistinguishable films, or maybe it's my increasingly jaded cinematic sensibilities, but for whatever reason, I found it difficult to separate the wheat of 2010's theatrical offerings from their chaff.
That's the bad news. The good news is that as a result, I now have double the number of movies to recommend to readers, and just because I can't endorse all of these pictures with the utmost zeal doesn't mean they aren't all worth adding to your Netflix queue.
So let's get to it. This post will provide the back half of the list, with the remaining 10 arriving shortly. Here are the Manifesto's Top
(Honorable mention: The American, Another Year, The Ghost Writer, Hereafter, I Am Love, Lebanon, Love & Other Drugs, Rabbit Hole.)
20. The Town. Ben Affleck has made some questionable decisions in the past as an actor (not to mention as a celebrity), but he's atoning in style as a director. His first feature, Gone Baby Gone, was a riveting thriller that flirted with masterpiece status; The Town isn't quite as good, but it nevertheless confirms Affleck as a filmmaker of considerable poise and confidence. The movie breaks little new ground, but its set pieces are executed with such speed and precision that they create genuine suspense. The acting is uniformly strong (an achingly vulnerable Rebecca Hall leaves the most lasting impression, as she always does), and the brisk pace never flags, even during the overlong climax. The Town may not be a great movie, but it's a thoroughly solid one that indicates that Affleck's best has likely yet to come.
19. You Don't Know Jack. HBO may be ceding some ground to AMC in terms of airing the best shows on television, but it remains the preeminent network when it comes to producing feature films. A compassionate, often captivating examination of Dr. Jack Kevorkian, Barry Levinson's You Don't Know Jack strikes a delicate balance between professional objectivity and personal outrage. Anchored by a committed Al Pacino – abandoning his late-period bluster and delivering his best performance since Insomnia in the process – Levinson's film is clearly political, but it employs a terse, matter-of-fact style that slyly camouflages its agenda without blunting its impact. Danny Huston turns in superb supporting work as Kevorkian's lawyer, but this is Pacino's movie, as he portrays with perfect clarity a man whose passion in life was his commitment to death.
18. The King's Speech. Depending on my audience, my assessment of 2010's Best Picture victor can vacillate from critical snorting to earnest support. On the one hand, I firmly believe that The King's Speech is the weakest title to take home Oscar's biggest prize since 2005. The visuals are drab, the story is utter cornball, and little about the film feels vital or fresh. On the other hand, the movie dispenses pure pleasure, dodging its underdog-hero clichés by employing a savvy mix of warm humor and heartfelt sincerity. Colin Firth is magnificent as a dignified man fumbling futilely for respect, while Geoffrey Rush is nearly as good as his wry, acid tutor. The King's Speech didn't deserve to win Best Picture, but that doesn't mean it isn't an enjoyable time at the movies.
17. Agora. Alejandro Amenábar's first English-language feature since The Others, Agora grossed a tepid $600 thousand at the domestic box office, as Newmarket showed little interest in promoting it. That's a shame, because American audiences missed out on an odd, often stirring blend of intimate drama and throwback epic. On one level, Agora is a rousing, straightforward tale of old-school religious conflict and barbarism on the scale of The Ten Commandments. Yet it also spends significant screen time on a subplot in which a woman (Rachel Weisz, in fine form) becomes obsessed with discerning Earth's position in the solar system. This latter focus on academic curiosity would seem incongruous with a sword-and-sandal saga, but Amenábar fuses them into a unified story with nimble dexterity. In the end, Agora is a film of true spectacle, whether dealing with a horde of Christian zealots or a diagram drawn in the sand.
16. Shutter Island. As a director, Martin Scorsese has always been playful, even when exploring such sordid subjects as simmering revenge or gangland violence, but in Shutter Island, he abandons any semblance of discipline. The resulting film is nonsensical but never mundane, grotesquely overwrought but furiously watchable. The plot is basically incoherent and essentially has nowhere to go, yet the movie somehow builds and builds, delving ever deeper into its deranged universe. That universe happens to be the mind of its protagonist, Teddy Daniels, and it helps that Daniels is played by Leonardo DiCaprio, turning in yet another jaw-dropper as a desperate man grappling with both the inmates of an asylum and his own inner demons. Hurtling from one bizarre sequence to the next, Shutter Island is a house of cards, threatening to tumble at the slightest breeze, but Scorsese and his star somehow keep us mesmerized, oblivious to the absurdity that surrounds us.
15. Never Let Me Go. The science-fiction label has recently attained a stigma of sorts, as it's usually appended to movies heavy on explosions and light on plot. Mark Romanek's Never Let Me Go, based on Kazuo Ishiguro's wildly popular novel, is technically a science-fiction film, but there's nary an action sequence or cyborg to be found. Rather, it's a hushed, hypnotic drama about the tyranny of disease and the fraying bonds of female friendship. Romanek operates at an unhurried pace that will irritate some viewers, but he lends his characters real depth and shading, and the film ultimately achieves a catharsis of surprising potency. Composer Rachel Portman essays the year's finest musical score, while Keira Knightley's acrid, hopeless yearning is a music all its own.
14. Barney's Version. Paul Giamatti is a magician of an actor. With his hangdog face, scruffy facial hair, and gruff voice, he's virtually the antithesis of a movie star, but he invariably transforms his characters from bumbling schlubs into everyman heroes of indefinable but undeniable charm. And Barney's Version is its irascible leading man personified. A sprawling character study that lurches from past to present and from one undercooked subplot to the next, the movie is a mess, but it's a wonderfully appealing mess, leavened with sharp humor and a central romance that is both highly improbable and deeply moving. Heartfelt supporting work from Rosamund Pike, Dustin Hoffman, and (against all odds) Scott Speedman help elevate the material, but it's Giamatti's winsome, soulful turn as the title character that redeems a film that first appears, much like its protagonist, to be irredeemable.
13. Dogtooth. "This movie is really weird," wrote a YouTube user posting a clip from Dogtooth. No kidding. Giorgos Lanthimos' demented satire of a family who takes home-schooling to the next level is occasionally depraved, frequently disturbing, and consistently transfixing. Lanthimos' style is one of cool, formal discipline, a rigor that helps undercut a story whose myriad absurdities include three incestuous siblings, two beatings involving home video equipment, and one mutilated cat. But Dogtooth's outright lunacy doubles as its strongest asset, as the film plunges us into its well-manicured wilderness and lets us forage for understanding without any guidance. The great pleasure of Dogtooth is not its madness but the manner in which that madness is gradually revealed, as we ever so slowly come to appreciate the depths of Lanthimos' twisted vision, even as we're horrified by the sight.
12. Let Me In. One of the finest films from 2008 was Let the Right One In, a Swedish concoction of equal parts savagery and tenderness. (Its director, Tomas Alfredson, is helming Tinker, Tailor, Solider, Spy, the long-awaited adaptation of the John le Carré smash due in November.) Depending on one's perspective, the decision to remake it just two years later was either a bald insult to Swedish cinema or a noble attempt to tell its story to subtitle-phobic American audiences (if the latter, it was a catastrophic failure, as it scraped just $12 million). Personally, I felt no need for a new version, but evaluated independently, Let Me In is damn impressive filmmaking, with director Matt Reeves sustaining a sinister mood of coiled suspense. Young actors Kodi Smit-McPhee and Chloë Grace Moretz are persuasive, but it's Reeves' patience and restraint – his refusal to rush – that lends the film an exhilarating, exhausting tension. Let Me In may have been unnecessary, but it lingers a long time afterward regardless.
11. True Grit. There probably wasn't any more need for the Coen Brothers to remake True Grit than there was for Matt Reeves to remake Let Me In, but I'm still not complaining, not when the Coens brought their trademark perfectionist craft to the screen. (Admittedly, I've yet to see the prior incarnation that gave John Wayne his lone Oscar.) In the Coen canon, True Grit is neither a diabolically clever tale in the mold of Blood Simple nor a ruthlessly unforgiving thriller à la No Country for Old Men. What it is, however, is the most relaxed picture the brothers have made since The Big Lebowski, an effortlessly told drama that pleases easily, even when it's trafficking in deception and murder. There's minimal subtext beneath True Grit, but there's much to behold on the surface, from Roger Deakins' magnificent cinematography to Jess Gonchor's immaculate production design to the Coens' rhythmic adaptation of Charles Portis' dialogue. The Coens have also done cinema a great service in discovering Hailee Steinfeld, the startlingly self-assured actress whose pitch-perfect performance shall remain in memory long after the spectre of this insubstantial, delightful film has faded.
Check back soon for Part II.